Lucy Muir from The Ghost and Mrs Muir
I’ve backdated this post, but the truth is it’s horrendously late. I simply couldn’t settle on November’s Woman of the Month. There were plenty of female characters to choose from, but some I want to save for a later date, some whose stories I haven’t finished yet, and none that really demanded I write about them. I was nearing the end of my rope when I cast my eye over September’s reading/watching log and was reminded of Lucy Muir.
Quite a few of the Woman of the Month entries I’ve been writing lately are just as much about the treatment of the female character within the context of her story, as the female character herself. For instance, also I considered writing about His Girl Friday’s Hildy Johnson, who is in the flummoxing position of wanting to get married and become a settled housewife, only for her ex-husband to manipulate her into reembracing her career as an ace reporter. Erm, is this a good thing or a bad thing?
In the case of Lucy Muir, there’s a lot to enjoy about a young widow who decides to seek out a life of her own, but who is technically caught up in a bittersweet romance story that requires her to utter lines such as: “I need companionship and laughter; all the things a woman needs.” Yes, like so many of her fellow heroines in movies of this period, Lucy equates not just happiness, but actual womanhood itself, with being in love and getting married.
Lucy is desperate to get away from her pushy in-laws after the death of her husband, and with the money left to her, she moves into a lovely seaside cottage, unperturbed by talk of the place being haunted. With her is her young daughter Anna and her faithful housekeeper Martha (if you squint, this trio could be construed as the maiden, mother and crone archetypes).
There she meets the ghost of sea captain Daniel Gregg, and the two gradually fall in love. But a living woman cannot marry a dead man, and on realizing that she has a mortal suitor, Daniel disappears from her life, telling her as she sleeps: “you must make your own life among the living, and whether you meet fair winds or foul, you’ll find your own way to harbour in the end.”
This assertion proves to be true when her suitor proves to be a cad, and Lucy must go on alone. And so she does! The final segment of the film follows Lucy into old age, in which it’s revealed that she had a rich, fulfilling life in the years that followed Daniel’s departure. She didn’t need a man after all!
What fascinates me is that a film made in the 1940s must naturally follow set “rules.” Despite it being billed as a romance, it cannot commit to a love affair between a ghost and a living woman. But because Daniel and Lucy are the film’s OTP, they can’t have her remarry another man either. She can’t die young, either by accident or by her own hand – she can only grow old and eventually reunite with Daniel when she passes naturally, and it’s in this narrative paradox that the character finds her freedom.
Lucy is a woman who seizes her chance, is unafraid of going it alone, raises her daughter well, and lives independently. Her life is filled with the things she loves, and she’s entitled to that life, so says the narrative. She lives it wholly and without regret. The subtext, whether the film means it or not, is she didn’t need a man after all!
It’s a lovely, quiet, understated portrayal of a woman whose unluckiness in love only underscores how rich she is in all other aspects of her life. As she says at one point: “You can be much more alone with other people than you are by yourself, even if it’s people you love.”

.png)
.png)
.png)

.png)
.png)