Search This Blog

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Reading/Watching Log #131

It’s October, which means my Tumblr feed is awash with images of autumn leaves, pumpkins, full moons and black cats, which is decidedly at odds with the weather we’re currently experiencing as the season edges into summer. And it’s going to be a hot one this year.

But we still celebrate Halloween at the same time as everyone else, though the weekend upon which Halloween took place had some pretty strange weather. The night before the 31st, I had a work function in which we all watched Sleepy Hollow – that day had gone from rain, to hot sunshine, to a thunderstorm (which was wonderfully fitting for the movie). Halloween itself was fairly fine, but a cold wind picked up around five o’clock… which is probably why I didn’t get any trick or treaters at my door. (It’s not really a New Zealand tradition, and Covid lockdowns pretty much destroyed what little there was, though you can tell some people are trying to bring it back).

But the theme of this year’s spooky season was WITCHES. Good ones, bad ones, ambiguous ones, clichéd ones, modern ones, fake ones… there’s plenty to choose from. 

This review of Bandidas points out something rather fascinating: that men come in pairs, women come in trios – especially if they’re witches. It’s no doubt because an awareness of the Fates and the Mother/Maiden/Crone triad lingers in our collective subconscious but you can see it everywhere: Macbeth, Hocus Pocus, The Witches of Eastwick – even Practical Magic has three sets of duos (the aunts, the sisters, and the daughters), while The Craft culminates in three bad witches pitted against one good one.

Of course, now that I’ve said it, I have to admit that only two of the things I’ve reviewed beneath the cut adheres to this rule: Charmed and Circle of Three. But the pattern is there, especially if you broaden the definition to female characters everywhere: The Powerpuff Girls, The Marvels, Charlie’s Angels…

Another interesting observation is that because of the significance of the Salem Witch Trials in American history, the visuals conjured up by New England and the Puritans are now an intrinsic part of the witchy aesthetic. The story will either posit that real witches were running around Salem (Hocus Pocus, I Married a Witch, Salem – duh) or at least mention it in passing, as though modern-day practitioners of witchcraft and Wicca were the true persecuted victims back in 1692 (Sweep, Charmed, The Secret Circle). And of course, Salem was the name of Sabrina Spellman’s talking cat.

The legacy of Salem also gave birth to (or at least heightened) fictional themes of persecution towards those who are different. Most witch-related stories include the threat of being identified or outed as a witch, which of course carries with it a LGBTQ+ subtext. It’s also not a stretch to theorize that this entanglement of secret identities and preternatural powers were the basis of superheroes such as the X-Men or stories that deal with the Christianization component of colonization (specifically things like Cursed, Merlin, the Grishaverse, or any other property in which magical minorities are targeted).

The waning fear over the existence of real witchcraft, coupled with the retrospective examination of religious persecution (which I touched on briefly in this essay), has led to an entire subgenre of fantasy-fiction surrounding a new archetype: Victimized Woman with Very Real Magical Powers. We’ll see a lot of this below the cut.

One last thing: because witches are so closely associated with folklore and myth, it was fun to see so many familiar devices and motifs pop up across such an otherwise wide range of tones and themes. For instance, the horror-comedy The Love Witch featured a brief play-fight between the Oak and Holly Kings, something that also turns up in one of the Circle of Three books, which is a fairly grounded series for teens designed to act as a fictionalized primer for studying Wicca.

And it turns out there were so many witch-related books, films and shows that interested me that I’m going to extend this theme into November. Even then, there’s so much stuff I have no chance of getting to: the two Sabrina shows, Sanctuary, Domino Day, Practical Magic 2, Good Witch, Salem…

Whaiao Presents: Folk Tales Performance (Christchurch City Libraries)

It was a last-minute decision to attend this little show, and it was largely due to my workplace giving out free tickets (plus, it was actually at my place of work, in one of the hireable rooms). It was a simple enough premise: three performers told stories and sang songs/waiata, though they leaned into one of my favourite subjects: how stories hold echoes of each other no matter how geographically far away from each other they’ve spread.

For instance, one of the performers told the Māori legend of the taniwha who stole the beautiful Waitaiki as she bathed in the sea. Despite the best rescue efforts of her husband Tamaahua, the taniwha eventually decides If I Can’t Have You, No One Can, and turns Waitaki into pounamu (greenstone), which is considered one of the great treasures of Aotearoa. The second performer then related the Scottish legend of the selkies and the man who managed to nab one of their sealskins in order to force her to marry him.

There are lots of similarities here: two women who are captured while in or near the sea, a man (or male figure) who looks upon her as something he can take for his own, and a transformation from or into something, that is both the woman’s punishment and her escape.

The performers were a little let down by the venue in which they had to perform – our hired room is more utilitarian than attractive, so hopefully they were able to get a better backdrop in the other libraries they visited. A few fairy lights and some foliage would have made all the difference, though the singing and music was beautiful no matter where it took place.

(And as it happened, one of the performers was Lizzie Tollemache, who I’ve not only seen in the Botanic Garden’s parodies of The Lord of the Rings and Titanic, but ten years ago in The Dunstan Creek Séance! So nice when local talent keeps turning up like that).

The Mice of Mushroom Forest by Zanna Goldhawk

This and the following book are by completely different authors/illustrators, and yet they’re similar in many ways: both depict light figures on dark backgrounds, both take place largely at nighttime, both have talking animals (especially mice) as their main characters, and both are rather whimsical despite realistic renderings of the natural world.

Fox roams the forest, making it dangerous for a mouse family to venture out of their burrow, but little Inky is intrepid enough to explore the beauty of the night forest, inspiring others to do the same. To defeat the fox, the mice rely not on kindness or trickery, but superior numbers, as the sight of them altogether forces him to flee. With the fox gone, the mice can enjoy the sun together, deciding that: “the forest belongs to everyone.”

It’s not a complicated story, and I was a little bemused that in dealing with the bully the mice essentially gang up on him instead of reaching an understanding through communication – but hey, if it works, it works. I suspect the true impetus of this book was a love of mushrooms, as the illustrations are filled with all kinds of them, dozens and dozens, rendered in vibrant luminescent colours of varying kinds, as well as several cross-sections of underground root life. It may be a slight story, but it’s worth it for the artwork.

The Underwater Moon by Sandra Dieckmann

This book works much better as an actual story, with illustrations that are just as interested in the subject of wildlife by night as The Mice of Mushroom Forest, but which is more coastal than woodland. For that reason, it also reminded me a lot of Marcus Pfister’s Milo and the Magical Stones.

Mouse lives by herself in a “creaky, old, gnarled tree,” with only the moon for company. Though she converses with it each night, she eventually grows frustrated that their conversations are completely one-sided, and throws a pebble at it. Unexpectedly, the moon falls into the sea. Yeah, I didn’t see that coming either.

Mouse sails out in a sardine can, and is rescued from harm by the marine and birdlife in the area, who soon start quarrelling over ownership of the moon. Eventually they realize that “the moon belongs to all of us” (another similar development to the previous book) and work together to put the moon back in its place. The illustrations are a bit awkward, as they show the moon atop an octopus, atop a whale that’s shooting water from its spout, with all the birds clustering around them, trying to push the moon upwards. It’s not a particularly convincing depiction of how these creatures might go about returning the moon to the sky, is all I’m saying.

But in the end, they all remain friends. A better story, but not a great one. That the moon can fall into the sea because it was hit by a pebble is a bit questionable, and it’s returned to the sky by even more unwieldly methods. Yes, I know it’s a kid’s book, but the image doesn’t have the whimsical logic needed required to pull off an idea like that.

But as with the previous book, we’re here for the illustrations. Dieckmann has also written/illustrated The Magic Feather, which has one of the most gorgeous covers I’ve ever seen. Here she highlights the beauty of the night shore, the drama of the waves, the luminescence of the moon... one two-page spread has to be turned vertically to capture the full range of the moon’s plummet into the water, and another two-pager captures the danger of Mouse alone and tiny on a restless sea.

Stacey’s Lie by Anne M. Martin

For some reason they always come up with the most generic Stacey titles, even though this book and its drama is actually quite juicy. School break is coming up and Stacey is gutted to learn she and her boyfriend Robert won’t have the chance to spend any time together: she’s going to New York to be with her father, and he’s taking a job on Fire Island. Yes, Fire Island, renowned destination spot for LGBTQ+ community and the setting of 2022’s Fire Island, a gay retelling of Pride and Prejudice. I keep meaning to watch that movie, it’s apparently very good.

In any case, her workaholic father surprises her by announcing that he’s taking two weeks leave, and gives Stacey the opportunity to chose any holiday spot she likes. The wheels in her head start turning and she goes with Fire Island. As a treat she gets to invite a friend along, and she of course goes with Claudia, though neglects to tell her that she’s hoping to find Robert there.

This is “the lie” of the title, though it’s more a lie of omission than anything. But her plan works, and she’s happily, sneakily reunited with Robert on the ferry, where he’s gotten his holiday job. On finding out, Claudia is a bit miffed, but goes along with it.

Unfortunately, things go south from there. Mr McGill disappears for hours at a time, presumably hanging out with their neighbour, Mr Majors (no, this does not go where you think it’s going). Claudia gets involved in an art project involving photographing sand castles on the beach, and that leaves Stacey free to spend her time with Robert. Still, even Claudia eventually gets frustrated with how often she’s being left on her own, and a fight erupts.

To make matters worse, Stacey and Robert go on a moonlit walk together and chance across Mr McGill and another woman – yup, turns out he’s been seeing someone secretly, and they agreed to meet on Fire Island for their first holiday together. Father and daughter are furious at each other, which is a bit rich since they’ve both been doing the exact same thing.

The rest of the babysitters (or at least Kristy, Mary Anne and Shannon) arrive on the island for their scheduled holiday, only to find everyone completely miserable. Claudia tries to convince them to join in a local parade, which nobody really wants to do (they feel too old for it, though you’d think the nightmare scenario of the Baby Parade would be a better reason not to get involved) but Claudia is gung-ho about it for some reason.

Their theme is a medieval fairy tale, with the girls dressed as jesters and dragons and princesses, dragging a sandcastle behind them on wagons. As with the float from the aforementioned baby parade, the logistics of this just hurts my brain. Please try and visualize this: “We picked up the board [with the sandcastle on top] and loaded it onto the four wagons, which Claudia had tied together with rope. Nearly three feet high and three feet wide, the castle was solid, wet sand. And every time we hit a bump, some of it crumbled.” 

That just hurts my imagination. Four wagons lashed together with a sandcastle on a wooden board balanced on top? Ouch. It gets worse, with Claudia’s jester shoes described as papier-mâché: “she’d constructed curly, pointed toes for her sneakers.” I’m sorry, but do you know how long it takes to make, sculpt and dry something out of papier-mâché? And how are they fastened to the tips of her sneakers??

Just to round things off, there’s also some weird continuity: “Krisy’s prince costume included…a sword we’d brought when we’d put on a video production of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs with the kids we sit for.” Okay, I give the ghostwriter credit for remembering this details from the video project… but why on earth would any of the girls bring along a fake sword for their beach holiday?

Unsurprisingly, the sandcastle collapses halfway through the parade and Claudia storms off, even though this was a profoundly stupid idea that no one wanted to be part of anyway. Stacey: “We didn’t bother to finish the parade, we just trudged home instead.”

The babysitters, plus Claudia, go home early the next day on account of the weather and the thoroughly hostile atmosphere at the McGill holiday home, and just to complete Stacey’s misery, Robert decides to break up with her after expressing how uncomfortable he is about the fact she lied to her friends and father. Having hit rock bottom, there’s nowhere to go but up, and Stacey gradually reconciles with everyone over the next few weeks (it’s a little anticlimactic).

The B-plot is Jessi and Mallory dealing with another case of feuding best friends while volunteering at a summer day camp: Haley and Vanessa end up at each other’s throats when they realize they’re wearing the exact same swimming togs at the local pool. Each accuses the other of copying her, and after making themselves and everyone around them miserable with their constant squabbling, Jessi and Mallory figure out a way to use their competitiveness against them: force them to work together to win at sports day. Needless to say, it works.

That’s it really, though I was bemused with Stacey’s justification as to why Claudia is vice-president: “she’s the only one of us who has her own phone line with her own number.” I’m glad they’re no longer interested in trying to pretend this role has any significance whatsoever.

Kristy and the Vampires by Anne M. Martin

Well, I’m pleased a Mystery title landed on the Halloween season, even if vampires was the theme of my October two years ago. Also, we’re not dealing with real vampires. Derek Masters is back in Stoneybrook to shoot a new film about (you guessed it) vampires. Unsurprisingly, everyone is super-stoked about a movie being shot in their little town, even though it sounds like crappy straight-to-video fare.

“Little Vampires” is about a foreign exchange student coming to smalltown America who is actually Dracula’s son, Vladimir, sent to recruit children into the ranks of vampirism. Were no Transylvanian youngsters available? Whatever the reason behind it, the plot involves him trying to ingratiate himself among regular kids only to eventually want to become one himself. Again, no explanation of how a vampire might revert back to a human being. The transformation is usually depicted as permanent.

Derek plays one of the kids who Vladimir tries to turn into a vampire, and his parents hire a sitter to watch over him while he’s on the set. That’s good foresight from them, though it remains unclear how a thirteen-year-old might defend him from an overbearing director if need be. Also, Jessi has always been Derek’s main babysitter, and it’s a little weird to see Kristy take over in the role.

Naturally, accidents start to occur: slips, breakages, stunts that go wrong – most seriously a pane of “breakaway” glass that Derek was scheduled to fall through is swapped out for the real thing, though luckily it’s discovered in time.

You know what this means – babysitters on the case! The girls put together a list of suspects: Carson, the teenage lead, who seems to think this shitty movie will be the making of his career, only he keeps messing up his takes around Derek, who is a consummate pro. Carson’s manager Frank may have the same motive, while Sheila the PR manager could be staging the accidents as a publicity stunt. Zeke the props master is fired in front of everyone after the glass incident, which could mean he’s out for revenge, while Cokie Mason is hanging around the set, trying to get Carson’s attention.

Obviously the culprit isn’t going to be a recurring character as prevalent as Cokie (though it would have been amazing if they’d gone through with exposing her as a stalker and arrested her) but there’s a very weak red herring in which she invites everyone to a pool party and they all come down with food poisoning. The babysitters seriously consider the possibility she’s trying to kill them all.

But it’s eventually revealed that a completely different character is to blame: a stalker called Lindsey Rockaway who set up all the near-serious accidents. Kristy realizes she plans to sabotage the Masters’ car in the most contrived way possible: would you believe me if a car manual fell out of Lindsey’s backpack that is not only conveniently dog-eared to a page about brake malfunctions, but that the sentences explaining causes of brake failure have been highlighted? Her motivation was that Derek was making Carson, the object of her obsession, look bad with his professionalism and skill.

So, Kristy saves the day, Lindsey is sent to a rehabilitation facility, and Dawn is hired by the Masters to perform the same job for them in California when filming relocates there, which is a nice way of keeping her involved in these stories. The final chapter is a range of clippings from various newspapers that are laughably enthusiastic about a terrible-sounding TV movie.

The B-plot is that Claire Pike is terrified of the thought of vampires in Stoneybrook, despite everyone telling her they’re not real. Instead of just letting her stay at home where she feels safe, her friends, family and babysitters keep dragging her to the set to see what’s going on – until the girls come up with the idea to dress her up as something even scarier than a vampire. This leads to the cover art: Claire dresses up as a witch, sees an actor dressed as a vampire, and tries to scare him. The actor plays along and Claire gets over her fear. That’s it.

Charmed: Haunted by Desire by Cameron Dokey

The month’s theme was witches and this was a Charmed tie-in novel, so I kind of had to read it. Do they even publish these officially sanctioned glorified paperback fan-fics for shows anymore? I kind of miss them. Cameron Dokey also wrote a couple of Buffy novels back in the day, as well as some of the Once Upon a Time series (not the television show – these ones) and she’s pretty good at capturing the spirit of what she’s adapting. 

Thing is, this is a tie-in from the original Charmed show so I got to tick the box on two sets of sisters (see below for season two of 2018’s Charmed remake).

This one seems to be set in the first half of season two, since Prue is still at Bucklands, even though Piper is managing P3 and Phoebe is taking college classes, which provides the impetus for the main plot of the book. For extra credit, Phoebe volunteers to research an infamous murder that took place on campus back in the fifties. Betty and Ronald were star-crossed lovers whose families disapproved of their relationship, and who snuck off to be alone during a college Halloween party.

At some point Betty’s best friend Charlotte went in search of them, only to emerge from a backroom covered in blood and screaming that Ronald was responsible. Witnesses saw him holding a knife over Betty, and after he flees the scene, he’s shot dead by the police.

Phoebe is convinced there’s more to the story than this, and begins her investigation – which just happens to involve calling up a few spirits for answers. Meanwhile, Prue and Piper are being targeted by a warlock who uses magic to make them infatuated with him. This B-plot is a bit of a slog, as even though they’re under a spell, their catty, childish behaviour toward each other makes them look terrible. I suppose it thematically matches the fact that the sixties killer turns out to have been Charlotte, who was jealous of the lovers, but even the sisters seem pretty bored with this plot.

But I can’t really bring myself to complain about this superfluous B-plot, or the fact that the mystery surrounding the murder is incredibly inelegant and badly plotted, because this sort of thing is precisely why Charmed was so much fun to watch in the first place. Even the demon being effortlessly vanquished was true to the nature of the original show.

The craziest thing about it though was how eerily prescient it was to my immediate circumstances. First of all, a character says: “since Halloween is coming up this Sunday…” I read this in the week leading up to Halloween, which landed on a weekend this year. Later, it mentioned that there’s “a current craze for swing dancing,” while I was literally listening to a live swing band in the Botanic Gardens. Then Prue is asked out on a date at a place called Michaelangelo’s – there’s going to be an exhibition of his work next month at our city hall that I’ve recently brought tickets to. And finally, there was an advert at the back of the book for Jenny Carroll’s Mediator series, which I was talking about with a customer a couple of weeks ago.

Okay, none of this is particularly impressive, but it was the spookiest thing to happen this Halloween.

Circle of Three: Books 1 – 5 by Isobel Bird

When I decided to make witches the theme of October, I knew I wanted to revisit several authors from my adolescence who wrote witchy books: Lois Duncan, L.J. Smith, Cate Tiernan and Isobel Bird (Silver Ravenwolf was working around this time as well, but her books were pretty awful). Isobel Bird wrote Circle of Three, a fifteen-book series about three teenage girls learning about Wicca.

The pitch was that this would involve a much more grounded depiction of magic, with nothing that couldn’t conceivably be experienced by real practicing witches (that is, no shapeshifting, demons, telekinesis, time travel and so on). After I made a request to Library Content, they purchased the whole series on e-book, which is most exciting since for the first time I’m going to read them from start to finish in their proper order.

Way back when I was a teenager, I had to read whatever was on the library shelf or going cheap at the bookstore, so I have never read them chronologically, and there are a couple I’ve never read at all – including the very last one! So yeah, I was very excited to get back to these. (That said, it can be quite fun to read a book series out of order, as the earlier ones end up feeling like prequels and the later ones are usually better anyway, the writer having established the world and characters and world-building).

It kicks off with So Mote It Be. Kate Morgan is a somewhat vapid highschooler whose most pressing matter in life is trying to get the cute jock she likes to pay attention to her. After checking out a book on witchcraft for a school project, she decides to cast a spell to attract love, just for the hell of it. To her shock, Scott Coogan starts to pay attention to her the very next day – along with most of the other boys in school.

Desperate for help, she checks the borrowing history of the spellbook and discovers it was previously read by two other girls: nerdy Annie Crandall and non-conforming Cooper Rivers. She reaches out, and the girls from three very different cliques discover a connection.

In Merry Meet, they decide to commit themselves to a year-and-a-day of studying the Craft within the Wicca community, specifically at Crones’ Circle (a magical supply shop and unofficial community centre for witches), which leads various rituals, circles and study groups. This is also the book that introduces Sasha, a runaway who becomes the trio’s unofficial little sister, and Tyler, a new love interest for Kate (though it gets more complicated later on).

Second Sight changes to Cooper as its POV character, who begins to have visions and premonitions of a missing girl called Elizabeth Sanger, while What The Card Said shifts to Annie, who discovers a talent for tarot card reading and unexpectedly experiences a surge in popularity after she performs some very accurate readings for her peers.

Into the Dreaming is the first book that contains perspectives from all three girls in a single volume, something that will continue until the end of the series. Here the trio attend a Midsummer Night festival, become separated, and have three very different magical experiences in the forest: Cooper with the Wild Hunt, Annie with the Oak and Holly Kings, and Kate with the Queen of the Fairies and her two love interests.

I only discovered this recently, but Isobel Bird is a pseudonym for Michael Thomas Ford, a real-life Wiccan practitioner. He captures the voices of his teenage girl protagonists reasonably well (I mean, I never suspected that a guy was writing these when I was a teenager, so I have to give him credit for that) though his key motivation is laid down in his first afterword: “There are a lot of young people interested in studying the craft now and I wanted to write something that was both fun to read and that would also give them a glimpse into the world of Wicca so that they could see what it was all about.”

First published in 2001, I doubt Ford had much confidence they’d ever get more than one print-run, as there’s no attempt made to make these books timeless. They’re filled with pop-culture references of the day, including mentions of Britney Spears, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Christina Aguilera, Ricky Martin, Blink 182, Shakespeare in Love, Ben Affleck and N’Sync, (Though hey, over twenty years later, most of those celebrities and bands are still household names!)

Then there are the things he couldn’t have known would date, including CD players and the fact the school library still uses circulation cards by stamping them with due dates. Someone also mentions a Valerie Bertinelli Lifetime movie, while one of Kate’s friends decides to go to a fancy-dress party with her boyfriend as Xena and Ares. (This made me realize that if these girls were turning sixteen in 2001, they’d be forty-one now).

Aside from all this, the stories have only mildly dated. The popularity of Wicca has certainly waned since the nineties/early noughties, and admittedly there’s something a little off-putting about three white girls calling on all sorts of goddesses from other cultures for their religious rites, as though ancient deities have nothing better to do than help teenage girls with their self-actualization journeys.

That said, perhaps the reason we as a species don’t really do fertility rites and blessings for the crops and rituals to ensure safe births anymore is because science has largely taken over the function of gods in dealing with these epochs of life. Maybe life-coaching teenagers is all the likes of Pele and Hecate and Freya have left to do.

But Ford is sincere about the self-proclaimed purpose of his novels, and takes the opportunity to get across the basics of Wicca: that it’s a religion, that it’s not based on a holy book or religious figure, that it revolves around ancient pagan festivals, that it’s constantly changing and that there are very few set beliefs. He even spends fourteen pages on an afterword that details how to make a papier-mâché mask.

I like that it leans into the year-and-a-day of study, since it starts at the beginning of summer and moves all the way through the months with the various festivals to mark the passage of time (Ostara in Merry Meet, Beltane in Second Sight, the Summer Solstice in Into the Dreaming). It’s a fun way to structure a series.

There are a lot of stock characters, from the high school Alpha Bitch to the nosy reporter who pesters teenagers for her next big scoop, and I had to crack a smile at the names given to the various members of the coven: Thatcher, Rowan, Archer, Thea – nothing too weird, but definitely names you’d expect from hippie-adjacent neo-pagans.

Okay, I may sound a little sarcastic, but I’m genuinely enjoying this walk down memory lane, as well as the experience of reading this story in its correct order (I remember vividly that as a teenager I read Merry Meet for the first time very late in the game, which felt like quite a disruption in the flow of events). Most of all, I appreciate that the focus is and remains on the unusual friendship of the three lead characters above all other considerations, without compromise. As Kate says to Scott at one point without any hint of irony: “A girl’s friends are very important. You’re a boy. You wouldn’t understand.”

Sweep: Books 1 – 5 by Cate Tiernan

Just like Circle of Three, this is a fifteen-book series that began in 2001 and dealt with the subject of teenage girls discovering the world of witchcraft. Unlike Circle of Three, this skews a lot darker, and features only a single protagonist (at least to start with).  

Morgan Rowlands (and yes, I’m amused we’ve got another “Morgan,” though as a first name instead of a surname this time around) is a typical American highschooler who doesn’t consider herself particularly special in any way, especially in comparison to her gorgeous best friend and little sister. That changes the day she meets Cal Blaire, a new student with Adonis good looks and charisma to burn, who moves from clique to clique and soon enough brings together ten handpicked students to form a coven, taking a special interest in Morgan when she demonstrates an aptitude for magic. Sorry, magick.

If all of this is throwing up some red flags, that’s because it’s meant to. Tiernan rather cleverly pulls off a Mid-Season Twist in which it turns out that Cal’s love bombing, careful grooming of an insecure teenage girl, and charismatic leadership/control of an exclusive group are all extremely bad news. He’s revealed to be the agent of his mother Selene, a powerful witch who moves from place to place, forming covens and then stealing their magick.

Along with all this, Morgan also finds out that she was secretly adopted as a baby, and is in truth a powerful blood witch whose biological parents were killed by a mysterious “dark wave” that’s been wiping out the Great Clans of witches for several decades – which may or may not be linked to Selene and Cal.

Now, all this puts Tiernan in a somewhat awkward writerly position. Though she draws heavily upon Wicca and Neo-Paganism for the basis of her depiction of magick, she also wants to tell a story involving the forces of evil and dark spellcasting and wicked witches, which modern practitioners of witchcraft find immensely inaccurate, if not downright offensive.

Where Circle of Three wanted to remain fairly grounded in Wiccan beliefs, Tiernan comes up with an imagined history for “blood witches” (which more or less translates to real witches with innate power, as opposed to mere dabblers and practitioners) and includes elements such as accelerated healing abilities, bringing plants back to life, magical chains that strip individuals of their magic, and so on. If memory serves, Morgan will eventually shapeshift into a wolf in a later book.

Obviously, very different writing prerogatives are behind this and Circle of Three, and it’s a wonder Tiernan didn’t face more backlash from the Wiccan community after coopting their name and practices to such an extent (of course, this was 2001).

But the most interesting and enjoyable thing about this book series is that it’s the closest thing to a television show I’ve ever read. TV shows at this time could be up to twenty-two episodes long, with seasonal arcs that had a beginning, middle and end. That said, a show could continue for as long as it was popular, which required a certain amount of flexibility regarding how they were written (for example, if an actor had to leave, they’d write them out; if a story-arc wasn’t working, they’d drop it). 

Writers would also have to compartmentalize stories into forty-five-minute segments, each with their own rising action and climactic crescendo, as opposed to just chopping up a larger story into multiple portions. Then there were the multitude of little subplots that were woven throughout the season which had little to nothing to do with the main story-arcs and were largely there to fill out the runtime (remember when Lana Lang on Smallville tracked down her bio-dad?)

The fascinating thing about Sweep is that all of these television-based features are present in the series. Tiernan clearly had a broad strokes grasp of where her story was going, while making up other parts as she went along. You can even spot the differences as you go: Tiernan definitely had a handle on the gist of Morgan’s gradual coming-of-age drama as she discovers the secrets of her past, taps into her inherent power and experiences heartbreak for the first time. But there are also dozens of little subplots going on at the same time, some of which get cut short as they lose their relevancy or fall by the wayside when she loses interest.

For instance, there’s an ongoing story-thread about Morgan’s little sister dating a guy who eventually assaults her, and how the sisters try to deal with it. There’s another involving her gay aunt who faces homophobic prejudice when she moves into a new neighbourhood. In one of the early books, Morgan is tailgated by someone, causing her to spin off the road and damage her car. We never discover who did this or why. 

The love-lives of Morgan’s coven members get explored, there’s a little mystery surrounding the magical supply store that Morgan regularly frequents, and one of the minor characters eventually has what can only be called a spin-off when she’s deemed interesting enough to get her own standalone book (though that comes much later in the series). There’s even a perfect example of We Hardly Knew Ye when the tenth member of Cal’s original coven – Beth Nielson – quits in the third book and is never seen or heard from again. Just to complete the noughties picture, she was the coven’s Token Minority who Morgan describes as having “coffee-coloured skin”. I’ve lost count of the times in which this sort of thing happened across long-running television shows of that era.

My point is that the whole series just captures that energy and structure of TV shows in that particular decade, where long-term arcs are mapped out, but there’s also a palpable sense of throwing things at the wall to see what will stick. With that in mind, a character called Clyda Rockapel is namedropped as Selene’s mentor, leaving me to wonder if she turns up later in the capacity of a Big Bad who got an Early-Bird Cameo (or at least mention) in the first five books. I honestly can’t remember.

It all makes for a fun reading experience, as well as a walk down memory lane in regards to how television used to work.

I did manage to read this series more-or-less in order as a teenager, though today I’m reading the stories in three-in-one volumes, which has the downside of each new entry feeling the need to reintroduce characters and recap situations that I’ve just read about. Not helping is that most of the stories end on a cliffhanger, so it got very annoying to simply turn the page and be faced with exposition explaining everything leading up to the moment that just ended the previous book. This no doubt was necessary if you were reading them at intervals while they were being published, but when it’s immediately one after the other? Not so much, and perhaps a little bit of editing for the sake of a three-in-one compilation would have helped.

There are some other notable aspects to the series: each chapter starts with a journal entry, though they’re usually unsigned or under a Gaelic name, requiring the reader to try and figure out who exactly they’re from (the dates provide clues) and there are plenty of specific details that add verisimilitude, such as Morgan’s car being named “Das Boot” or the Rowlands family using the phrase “in the dollhouse” instead of “doghouse” due to Morgan’s sister mishearing the idiom when she was a little girl.

There’s also a positive depiction of the Catholic Church which made for a nice change of pace (Morgan has nothing against Christianity, she just realizes it’s not for her anymore) and plenty of amusing callbacks to 2001: Morgan doesn’t have a cellphone, and when the phoneline is busy, she assumes someone must be online.

Altogether, there’s nothing like reading trash that’s reasonably well-written and which contains some pretty solid narrative ideas. I’m looking forward to the next ten books.

I Married a Witch! (1942)

A few years ago I wrote on fictional witches and the big problem the subject always has to contend with: people are terrified of women with hard power. Heck, that fear is the reason the concept of witches was invented in the first place! It gave society an excuse to control and punish women that stepped out of line.

But the concept of the witch is also alluring for storytelling purposes, and there are multiple ways of using it: witches as villains, witches as superheroes, or witches as people not doing anything more assertive than casting love spells and brewing potions. A lot of the time, a witch will eventually relinquish all her power for love.

As I asked in my linked essay, what would a proactive witch operating in the real world look like? A witch who actually used her power to change society in a dramatic, widespread, positive way? The sisters of Charmed don’t really count, since they’re essentially superheroes who use their abilities to fight demons and warlocks and other threats that aren’t real. Even in the universe in which they live, such things are contained within a secret subworld. But we get glimpses of it now and then – Rochelle uses her abilities to punish a racist bully in The Craft, Miss Price fights Nazis in Bedknobs and Broomsticks, Jennifer magically rigs an election so that her husband becomes governor in I Married a Witch – but in all such cases, the spell comes with consequences. And I know better than to touch on Hermione’s house-elf campaign in Harry Potter.

But what if (for example) the Halliwells used their powers to punish rich people who escaped justice? What if the Owens sisters used potions to destroy systemic corruption? What if Sabrina Spellman and Samatha Stephens and Wanda Maximoff banded together to dismantle misogyny throughout the world’s governments? What if all this was done on a widespread, consistent scale, until the world became a better place?

Sorry, but that’s completely off-limits to any witch: you’re either fighting dark supernatural forces, or you’re casting benign little spells to improve your love life and make herbal bath salts. Worst of all, sometimes witches are required to give up their power in order to secure a happy ending. This happens quite often, even outside the witch genre: Princess Elionwy, Arwen Undomiel, Alina Starkov, Yvaine in Stardust – they all lose their magical gifts by the end of the story and often their motivation is love for a man.

And yes, I know there are plenty of stories in which preternatural men lose or forfeit their powers. But when it happens to female characters, the narrative usually frames it as a natural, welcome thing. (In fact, I can only think of one example of a magical woman who lived to regret giving up her magical abilities to marry a man, and that was the unnamed antagonist in the second episode of Constantine that I watched only a couple of months ago. That’s a pretty obscure example). But when Superman does it so he can have sex with Lois Lane, it’s regarded as completely abhorrent and reversed as quickly as possible.

Okay, I should probably talk about this movie, but I promise all that stuff is relevant. When I wrote the above essay, I acknowledged there were a few stepping stones missing in the progression of witch-related stories that I touched on, and I Married a Witch is definitely one of them. It obviously inspired Bewitched, what with a magical wife whose powers cause trouble for her dullard husband, but there’s also something of Practical Magic here too, in how the members of a certain family are cursed to be unlucky in love thanks to a witch.

In colonial Salem (where else?) a witch and her father are sentenced to death, their ashes buried beneath an oak tree to imprison their spirits. The witch in question – Jennifer – curses her lover and accuser Jonathan Wooley, condemning him and all his descendants to unhappiness in matrimony. And so it is, all the way up until the present day, when Jennifer and her father Daniel are freed from the tree when it’s struck by lightning and topples to the ground.

The latest Wooley descendant is a man called Wallace, about to marry the shrewish Estelle as a publicity stunt for his political campaign. Jennifer sees an opportunity to mess with him, and the inevitable hijinks ensue. It’s all quite fun and light and charming, existing at an interesting point in the history of fictional witches in which one could be malicious, dangerous and otherworldly, but also sexy, appealing and (most importantly) tameable.

As I’ve already mentioned, Jennifer eventually relinquishes her powers and becomes a normal married woman (on her wedding night, she states: “I must start learning to be a good housewife.”) Much like Gillian in Bell, Book and Candle or Eglantine Price in Bedknobs and Broomsticks, she’s last seen as thoroughly domesticated, in this case by knitting in a chair with her hair up. Such is the natural order of things, and it’s no big loss anyway since when witches use their power, it’s usually for small, silly or selfish reasons. At least according to most of the films about them.

Bedknobs and Broomsticks (1971)

There is no understating just how obsessed I was with Bedknobs and Broomsticks as a kid. After being showed it at school, I (somehow) found my own copy and watched it incessantly. Returning to the film after a decades-long hiatus, I surprised myself with just how much dialogue and details I had retained.

Yes, it’s very much inspired by Mary Poppins, right down to the presence of David Tomlinson, though in a markedly different role. Based on the duology by Mary Norton, author of The Borrowers (I really must read those books in full one day) it’s a rather odd movie in terms of its episodic structure. It may well be the closest thing Disney has ever done to a Studio Ghibli film in regards to its composition, tone, and relatively low stakes.  

Set in 1940, three orphans called Charles, Carrie and Paul are evacuated to the Dorset coast to escape the bombings in London. They’re put in the care of Miss Price, a rather pinch-mouthed older woman who clearly resents the imposition. They plan to run away back to London the first chance they get, only to spot Miss Price flying around her house on a broomstick by night. Sensing an opportunity, they try their hand at blackmail, only for Miss Price to suggest to an arrangement: they’ll keep shtum about her identity as a witch, and she’ll gift them with a valuable object in return.

This object is a magical bedknob, which allows the bed upon which it is screwed to take its occupants anywhere in the world they might wish to go. And eventually, Miss Price wants to go to London to find Professor Emelius Browne, headmaster of the (abruptly closed) correspondence school of witchcraft she’s been attending.

What follow is a series of vignettes that are strung together by Miss Price’s desire to get her hands on a specific spell that she thinks might help in the war effort. There’s the search for Mr Browne in London, a sojourn into a cartoon land of talking animals, and finally a climatic sequence in which Miss Price leads bespelled armour into battle against a Nazi raiding party. It’s a movie that’s also somehow a television show. Oh, and Bruce Forsyth is here too! Wild.

There are catchy but superfluous songs that could have easily been cut, an adventure that’s rendered completely pointless since the magical words the characters were looking for were in a children’s book in Paul’s possession the whole time, and a lengthy sequence at Portobello Road which is given over to various extras just dancing in the street. Is it a tribute to all the allied nationalities that fought in WWII? Maybe, but it goes on for so long and has nothing whatsoever to do with the actual story.

For the record, I wouldn’t change a thing – and it wasn’t until this viewing that I found out for the first time that there’s actually a longer cut of this film, which was originally trimmed down by nearly half an hour for its premiere. Though some footage has been irrevocably lost, an unedited version was released in 1996, including three whole songs and more scenes involving the local priest (which makes sense of the fact that he was third-billed in the closing credits, despite minimal screentime). Naturally, I’m going to have to track that down.

Within the higglety-pigglety plot, there are two moments of genuine pathos. Early on, the children find a nursery in the grand old house that Mr Browne is squatting in, and though the scene exists to establish Paul finding a narratively-important picture book, it takes its time in showing the children exploring the room and looking at the toys. Carrie picks up two dolls and starts to rock them in her arms, and you can tell this is the first time she’s ever had the chance to do such a thing.

Later, when Mr Browne realizes that Nazis have invaded the small town of Pepperinge Eye, he breaks into Miss Price’s workroom where she keeps all her spells, and tries to use one to turn himself into a rabbit. It doesn’t seem to be working, so he gives himself a talking-to in the mirror: “now for once in your life you’ve got to believe in something.” And of course, it works.

Finally, it’s rather stirring to see all the armoury of British history come to life in order to defend its shores, like the return of King Arthur or the trees coming to Dunsinane – even though their eerie advance is completely undermined by the slapstick battle that follows. Likewise, the limitations of the special effects won’t allow for a full rout, though there is a surprisingly poignant end when the sentient armour simply sinks down to the ground. It doesn’t fall, but sinks.

I’ll say it: I prefer this to Mary Poppins. Miss Price is a more appealing character than Mary, there’s a greater sense of purpose, and the side adventures are charming because, rather than despite, their redundancy. But because this was set in 1940 and came out in 1971, the film does not allow Miss Price to retain her magical abilities. The Nazis destroy her workshop, and her memory is repeatedly established as so poor that it seems unlikely she’ll be able to recall any of the words to her spells.

Still, I mentioned in my review for I Married a Witch that witches are usually depicted as using their power “for small, silly or selfish reasons,” and in that I have to give the film credit for allowing Eglantine Price to have very noble motivations and goals. I mean, it doesn’t get more heroic than becoming a witch to fight Nazis.

Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992)

This was the choice of Halloween Night movie that myself and two former co-workers agreed upon all the way back in October last year when we went to see Dracula: The Ballet together, though there’s not a lot to say given I’ve spoken extensively on it only quite recently. Watching with a friend (sadly the other was unwell) brought a fresh perspective to the proceedings and I could appreciate through fresh eyes just how unafraid it is to be really fucking weird.

The choppy editing, the practical effects, the clumsy blocking – it often feels like people are too afraid to make these kinds of films anymore, at least as mainstream pictures that adapt famous novels. Still, I love getting immersed in its quirks, and as in Sleepy Hollow, the opening score has long-since fused itself to my bones. Where Elfman’s score is eerie and ethereal, this is heavy and laden with doom – both are equally effective at setting the mood and giving me chills.

I’d love to see a cut that restores and replaces some of the extended footage, if not just for the Mina/Jonathan reunion at the film’s conclusion, as I do think the insertion of a love affair between Mina and Dracula has doomed us not only to countless more depictions, but a barrage of dark romance that isn’t nearly as compelling as this somehow manages to be.

The Frighteners (1996)

I first saw The Frighteners when I was about fourteen years old and I LOVED it. I got my hands on a copy and watched it religiously for years, until finally buying the Director’s Cut on DVD – though as of this viewing, I hadn’t seen it in at least a decade (it was one of the choices for Halloween Movie Night at work – it didn’t win, but the poll left me with the overwhelming desire to see it again).

All these years later, it mostly holds up. It’s a little tonally off (the jokes aren’t nearly as funny as Peter Jackson seems to think they are), doesn’t really get going until the Grim Reaper turns up, and a lot of the CGI looks downright bad by today’s standards, but once it hits its stride it’s a great supernatural mystery (my favourite kind, see also: the Fear Street trilogy and Sleepy Hollow).

This time around I also paid more attention to the background shots, as this was filmed in Lyttleton, which is only a half-hour drive away from where I live. I’ve looked down on that bay so many times, walked those streets – and this time around I even noticed a shop sign in the movie that says: “Lyttleton”! (Look closely in the scene where Ray’s ghost is first seen running towards Frank). 

Michael J. Fox is Frank Bannister, a former architect who is currently working as a ghostbuster/exorcist – the catch being that he’s in league with the ghosts sent to haunt whatever house he thinks could turn a profit. There’s obviously a dark history at work here, especially once it’s established that people who see spirits usually gain that ability after a traumatic experience. Things start to go awry when Frank’s latest victim/client Ray Lynskey dies suddenly after another fake exorcism. He leaves behind his grieving widow Lucy, and a strange clue: not long before he died, Frank noticed the number 37 etched into his forehead in fiery letters.

It seems to have something to do with the mysterious heart attacks that’ve been happening all over Fairwater for the past few years. As the bodies start to pile up, so too do Frank’s sightings of a terrifying cloaked-and-hooded Grim Reaper figure. What’s it all got to do with a massacre that took place at the local hospital back in the sixties? What’s with the numbers appearing on the foreheads of the victims, and how is it connected to the supposedly accidental death of Frank’s wife? How’s he supposed to help when he’s being pursued by law enforcement and a crazed FBI agent?

Like I said, it’s a great little mystery where the clues are supernatural in origin and so have to come with their own set of narrative rules; rules which are largely adhered to (there’s a little bit of cheating here and there, like how it’s never really clear about what ghosts can do, or how they can “die” a second time) but those are details and not really what the mystery is about. I don’t even mind that the villains are ultimately taken out by a Deus Ex Machina, since (no spoilers) Frank has to go to such drastic lengths to get them to a point in which a cosmic trap can be sprung. Plus, I like the idea that after a certain point, greater supernatural forces finally make themselves known in order to intervene in earthly affairs (see also: the Ark of the Covenant).

Another thing I appreciate in stories like this is connective tissue; that is, the ways in which characters learn information or let the audience in on how they know certain things. This movie is usually pretty good at doing this, though the one time it doesn’t makes for a solid example of what not to do.

For instance, towards the end of the film Frank voices the need to get some ashes to holy ground, and Lucy tells him there’s a chapel at the old sanatorium. I was watching this with a friend, who pointed out the seeming plothole that the character who’s been established as having only lived there for a few months knows more about the geography of Fairwater than Frank does – but then we remembered that at the beginning of the film, Lucy watches a video about the original massacre, which mentioned the existence of a chapel at the hospital.

Then there’s the coroner Doctor Kamins, a minor character who’s woven throughout the film. Towards the start, he’s mentioned in relation to the latest death in Fairwater – because he’s attending the funeral, Lucy has to go to the Bradley household in his place. We see him for the first time at the police station, giving important exposition about the nature of the mysterious heart attacks, and we can infer this was the guy Lucy was covering for since he recognizes her when she enters the building in relation to the most recent death. Finally, he turns up at the clinic to help resuscitate Frank after his botched attempt to take out the Reaper. It all knits together really well.

Then there’s the ghost that Frank meets while he’s on the other side, who has the number 12 etched on his forehead. He was the last victim of Bartlett’s original massacre, and sure enough, the same actor appears in the flashbacks that Frank starts to experience while he’s running about the wards in the present day. This is a great sequence, and the flashbacks allow him to find out where the chapel is, as he overhears a doctor telling a couple of nuns how to get there. It’s an underrated component of all good stories: this organic flow of information.

Of course, there is also one contrived moment that stands in interesting contrast to the elegance of the rest: at about the halfway mark, the movie really needs Lucy to return to the Bradley household (she Doylistically needs to find Frank’s missing switchblade in Mrs Bradley’s closet, an important clue). To achieve this, it conveniently has her visit Frank’s half-built house just in time to hear Mrs Bradley leave a message on his answering machine, demanding his help in exorcising demons from her daughter Patricia, who is heard screaming in the background.

This certainly gives Lucy the impetus she needs to return to them, but even putting aside the coincidence of being in the exact right place at the exact right time to hear that message, there has never up until this point been any sort of relationship established between Mrs Bradley and Frank that would justify why she would call him in this moment. Furthermore, when Lucy arrives at the Bradley House, everything is completely calm, and the bizarre message she overheard is never referred to again.

No, it’s not an important detail and the movie doesn’t hinge on its success, but the contrivance of it is a good contrast to the more considered writing throughout.

Miscellaneous Observations:

On thinking about it, there are plenty of odd creative decisions throughout this film. Peter Dobson gets top billing as Ray Lynskey, only to leave the film fairly abruptly around the halfway mark. At first it seems like he and Frank are going to work together in a Vitriolic Best Buds sort of way, but he’s ultimately just a device to bring Frank and Lucy together. Nobody ever learns what happened to him (he gets re-murdered by the Reaper), and so from Frank’s point-of-view, he just stormed off into the night and was never seen again.

The fate of John Astin’s Judge is even stranger: after the museum sequence he simply disappears from the film without explanation. There was originally a scene that had him appear to Frank and Lucy at the very end of the film (along with the ghost hound-dog, who is otherwise never seen outside of the scene in which he’s introduced) but this wasn’t restored to the Extended Edition, so we’re left assuming he’s destroyed by the Collector when he’s bisected by the Reaper’s scythe. But then – why is he not seen in heaven along with Cyrus and Stu?

If you’re going to have a jerk as a protagonist, it’s a good idea to cast an inherently likeable star like Michael J. Fox in the role, though Jeffrey Combs as Milton Dammers is perhaps a bit much. I guess someone in the cast felt they had to out-Busey Gary Busey.

The last name “Lynskey” is no doubt in tribute to Melanie Lynskey who briefly cameos in the film as a police officer.

The opening sequence, in which Patricia is screaming with terror as she’s pursued through her house by a specter, poses the question of why she’s so scared if she and Johnny were in cahoots together. I initially thought that this might have been the first time she called up his spirit, and he’s just indiscriminately attacking everything around him – but then that would require a substantial time-skip between this scene and the rest of the movie, as the duo are eventually revealed to be responsible for the death of Frank’s wife, an event established as having taken place five years ago. The more sensible interpretation is that it was just a sex game, since the Extended Cut revealed they did things like this. (Though her fear seems very real and the explanation is obviously not in the theatrical cut).

It’s very difficult to buy Fairwater as a smalltown in California, much less America (at least until the cops start shooting indiscriminately into crowds of civilians) as it all looks so kiwi. Not helping are all the Shortland Street actors, who must have been pretty chuffed to work alongside Michael J. Fox.

It struck me during this latest rewatch: what is up with the numbers appearing on people’s foreheads? Who or what is actually putting them there? I suppose most people assume it’s Johnny Bartlett marking his next victims through psychic/demonic means since while he was alive, his calling card was carving numbers on foreheads. But once he’s the Grim Reaper, the numbers appear on his victim’s foreheads before their deaths. That pre-emptive numbers are involved suggest certain people are being targeted, but then how does he choose them? The victims seem like random selections, even though the Reaper does go after the ones with numbers to the exclusion of all else.

The better explanation is that Bartlett is killing indiscriminately, and the numbers are actually appearing via Frank’s psychic abilities, giving him a head’s up as to who’s going to be next.

Sleepy Hollow (1999)

I watch this movie (almost) every Halloween, and this year I watched it with a fair chunk of my co-workers at our bi-monthly movie night. Yeah, I still love it. The American Gothic aesthetics/Tim Burton vibes are impeccable, and it was the very first horror film I ever saw in cinemas, which means it’ll always have a special place in my heart.

But I’ve already commented on it extensively in the past (here and here). What to add? Instead of going over what I’ve said many times before, I’ll write a little mini-essay about the use of cardinals as a symbol throughout the film. In real life, the cardinal is believed to be a sign of lost loved ones, or a promise of hope in the winter months, as well as a general symbol of romance and devotion. All this applies to the appearances of cardinals in Sleepy Hollow.

Everyone remembers the hilariously fake animatronic cardinal that Katrina points out at the abandoned cottage, but would you believe me if I said there are three more cardinal sightings throughout the movie?

More interestingly, they are linked not only with significant female characters, but themes of witchcraft, optical illusion, and the Caged Bird Metaphor. The obvious one is the thaumatrope that Ichabod carries with him, depicting a cardinal on one side and a cage on the other, first seen when Katrina wishes for a tame cardinal, but commenting she would not have the heart to cage it. Icabod’s device fulfils her desire, and though she claims the illusion is “magic,” Ichabod gives her a scientific reason as to why the image of the cardinal appears inside the cage when the thaumatrope is spun.

The thaumatrope is seen twice more, first in a flashback where it’s established it originally belonged to his mother, who uses it to sooth her son’s fears during a storm. The repeated image of the cardinal visually connects Lady Crane to Katrina, who has other things in common with her: both are first seen blindfolded for a game, both draw the same spirals in the ash of a fireplace, and both – as we eventually learn – are witches). This specific cardinal is seen again close to the climax of the film. Ichabod fiddles with it in the carriage as he figures out the solution to the mystery, and that (as the thaumatrope indicates) an optical illusion is at work. The body of Lady van Tassel is not hers after all.

In this instance, the cardinal serves the rationality theme, validating Ichabod’s insistence on reason and his trust in scientific methodology. But the very first time we ever see a cardinal onscreen is back in New York, in which Ichabod releases a caged one from his apartment and sets it free through an open window – which is a bit of a Call-Forward to Katrina later claiming she could not bear to ever cage a cardinal. 

What we see in this scene is an act of kindness since Ichabod’s journey to Sleepy Hollow means the bird could not be cared for in his absence, but if we also take it to embody the memory of his mother and the “caged bird” of Katrina (who is hiding her true identity as a witch) then Ichabod is the path through which the latter will be set free. The idea that Katrina is suffering from Small Town Boredom is more apparent in deleted footage (there’s an early scene between herself and Ichabod in his room in which she expresses interest in the operas and theatres of New York) and in doing so also captures a very neat example of the Caged Bird Metaphor.

In response, Ichabod will not only show Katrina the freed/caged bird of the thaumatrope but eventually take her to the big city, where a new life is waiting for her. So the greater part of the cardinal as a symbol is feminine as well as mystical in nature.

But there is one more appearance from a cardinal in this film, though it’s very blink-and-you’ll-miss-it: a dead one in the hand of the Crone just before she performs the spell/possession for Ichabod that gives him important information about the Horseman. It was clearly put there on purpose, so what gives? My interpretation is it’s a visual indicator that although the Crone is mildly terrifying (the cardinal in this instance is dead, after all) she can be trusted. This is the same bird that connects Ichabod’s beloved mother to his love interest, and the Crone is made part of that connection.

So the cardinal expresses duality: the country and the city, the caged and the freed, the living and the dead, science and witchcraft, and how closely they exist in connection with each other. Heck, the cardinal is named such because its plumage reminded early settlers of the red robes and mitre hats of high-ranking bishops, and in the context of this movie, amidst the corruption of the church embodied in Ichabod’s father and Reverend Steenwyck, there is truth to Christianity’s power – the Horseman cannot breach the church and his hatchet turns to ash when it lands on holy ground. So the cardinal also bridges the gap between Christian belief and the old ways of paganism.

It even links male to female, since the distinctive red cardinals are always male, and the characters they’re most associated with (Katrina, Lady Crane, the Crone) are all female. The cherry on top is that these three female characters easily slot into the three aspects of the Hecate Sisters: the Crone is self-evidently the Crone, Lady Crane is quite literally the protagonist’s Mother, and Katrina completes the triad as the Maiden. Whew, as symbols go, the cardinal does a lot of work for only a few seconds of screentime.

The Wolfman (2010)

This movie may feel like the odd one out, but given our movie night at work was Sleepy Hollow (witches) and my annual Halloween movie at home was Bram Stoker’s Dracula (vampires), I felt compelled to make an unofficial trilogy of it and watch this as well, just to cover the werewolf angle. It completes the set and vibes a lot with the other two – Anthony Hopkins appears here and in Dracula, Danny Elfman did the score for this and Sleepy Hollow, and all three enjoy uncredited cameos by thespians such as Max von Sydow, Martin Landau and Anthony Hopkins again (he was the priest in the prologue of Dracula).

One day I’ll do the same with Luc Besson’s Dracula: A Love Story, Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein, and Robert Eggers’ Werwulf (which also forms a natural trilogy in my mind, swapping out witches for Frankenstein’s Monster).

But The Wolfman just isn’t as good as the other two. Regardless of how filmic adaptations of Dracula and Frankenstein may deviate from their source material, Wolfman’s flaws might be because it’s not derived from a preexisting novel, but is rather a remake of the Universal film from 1941, which in turn is simply based on general folklore about the creature. Everyone knows who Dracula and Frankenstein are, but drop the name “Lawrence Talbot” into conversation and I suspect all you’ll get are blank looks.

The Wolfman may be a staple part part of the classic Monster Mash line-up/Hammer Horror films canon, but he’s also much less defined than the others. Vampires are about seduction and disease, Frankenstein is about scientific hubris, witches in all shapes and forms are largely about power (or the lack of it), but werewolves are about insanity – and there’s only so much you can do with that. Sometimes it can be hereditary insanity, which brings filial conflict into the equation, and this movie does attempt to use this angle to put some meat on bare bones, along with a lukewarm romance – though you never feel particularly invested in any of it.

Neither does the script carry any sense of suspense or restraint. The werewolf is seen far too soon, thereby robbing the viewer of anticipation or even a sense of doubt (compare to Sleepy Hollow, where the first couple of murders deliberately keep the Horsemen out of sight). It also answers the question of what happened to Lawrence’s brother too quickly, rendering his return to Talbot Hall rather anticlimactic. It also just occurred to me that the transformative nature of the werewolf means it’s the only iconic monster to involve a hidden identity, so why not allow Lawrence to search for his estranged brother, thereby casting doubt over who the werewolf really is, or if it’s even real in the first place? That there could be a slow and steady escalation of violence doesn’t seem to have occurred to anyone.

Then there are the odd narrative cul de sacs – what was up with Max von Sydow’s character and why did he give his wolfshead cane to Lawrence (which is ultimately only used by two characters that aren’t Lawrence)? Aberline gets a second-in-command called Carter who is later seen dead in a chair at the Talbot house without any explanation of how he got there or what happened to him. There’s a brief scene in which Lawrence seems to be stalking a woman in London, who looks like she recognizes him, but then she’s never seen again. Really, the plot is not only all over the place, but it keeps shifting gears. All the pieces are here, but it never seems to click.

Still, this time around I realized that the weird child-creature that Lawrence keeps seeing in his nightmares is actually the feral werewolf that originally passed the curse to his father (I would have liked to have found out what happened to him) and Retroactive Recognition plays its part, with surprise appearances from Gemma Whelan, Simon Merrells (the villain in The Winter King) and about half the guest-stars from Merlin: Asa Butterfield (young Mordred), David Schofield (King Alined), Michael Cronin (Geoffrey of Monmouth), and good old Clive Russell (King Bayard, though you’ve also seen him in pretty much everything else that exists).

Also, someone called David Sterne who certainly looked familiar, and is credited as being “the apothecary” in Merlin and “old man” in the BBC’s Robin Hood and Dymas in Atlantis and Abel North in The Living and the Dead and “annoying old man” in The Wheel of Time and “coachman” in Enola Holmes 3 AND “blind beggar” in Da Vinci’s Demons. I’ve no idea who any of those characters are, despite watching all these things semi-recently.

Coven of Sisters (2020)

I’ll admit I went into this one with no prior knowledge as to what it was about, simply betting on it being witch-related on account of the word “coven” in the title. And it was – sorta. This film is set in the Basque region, that is, the “both but neither” area of land in the northern part of Spain, just on the border of France. Its people were unsurprisingly “othered” by the countries on either side of it, and I was fascinated enough to disappear down the rabbit hole of its history and culture for a few hours.

It’s 1609 and the inquisition has come to a small fishing community, wasting no time in arresting five teenage girls on suspicion of witchcraft and inflicting upon them their no-win scenario interrogations. Terrified of what’s happening to them, their de facto leader Ana comes up with a plan – she confesses to witchcraft and insists on the innocence of the other girls. Betting on the deep fascination Judge Rostegui has for the Witches’ Sabbath, a gathering he believes exists but has never seen, Ana spins him tales of what happens there and promises to take him to one by the next full moon.

It’s all a stalling tactic to drag out the inquiries until the men of the village (currently on a fishing expedition) come home and are able put an end to the persecution of their daughters. Such is the plan, anyway.

The film touches on the themes you’d expect: the cruelty of the patriarchy and the bonds of sisterhood, but it’s not without nuance. Like most teenage girls, these ones squabble with each other as much as they nurture and protect, though the priests are fanatical, corrupt and/or lecherous down to a man. I’ll probably never watch this again, but it was engrossing while it lasted.

The Love Witch (2016)

Well, that was certainly something. Clearly based on the sexploitation horror films of the sixties and seventies, this leans heavily into stylized visuals and saturated colour, with garish sets and deliberately stilted acting. It’s almost worth it just for the flawless homage to a very specific type of film. I also have to commend it for being the work of a singular vision, in which you can tell everything is exactly the way writer/director Anna Biller wants it to be, even if you’ve no idea what’s actually going on.

It wasn’t even until afterwards that I realized she had handmade all the costumes used in the Renaissance Fair sequence – which explains why the film can feel a little self-indulgent at times, and is perhaps a half-hour too long. But hey, if I’d made all those costumes BY HAND, I’d be showing them off too.

Elaine is making a fresh start in California, her voiceover telling us she’s trying to put her life back together after the death of her husband, though there’s clearly more to the story than that. She settles into her new home and starts to make friends, but such is her desperate need for love that she immediately starts seducing men, who all ultimately come to sticky ends.

It’s hard to know what to make of the plot, and I was surprised to realize it came out in 2016 since it’s an almost too-perfect sendup of the tradwife phenomenon – the “almost” because Elaine is into New Age witchcraft and not white nationalist Christianity. I don’t think we even had the word “tradwife” ten years ago, but she believes as they do: that her worth depends on her being sweet and sexy and adored; a man’s fantasy as opposed to a human woman. Her mindset is doomed to fail her, and she quite literally ends up killing the men she gets entangled with.

So, is it a cautionary tale for women? For men? Watching it today, I couldn’t help but feel it would have been an even more pointed satire if it had been about a tradwife and not a witch, though I suppose Biller is having a poke at any ideology that spouts seemingly positive/inspiring talking points designed to manipulate women into submission, or people who self-centredly reinterpret these points to serve themselves (as Marcia Brady once said: “haven’t you ever heard of women’s lib? It means women get everything they want!” In her case, she wanted the bedroom to herself).

Maybe it’s about how the patriarchy always finds a way to trick women into oppressing themselves, whether it’s warping New Age teachings into “and this is why you should have sex with me,” (I’m reminded of how Neil Gaiman and Joss Whedon used a veneer of feminist-friendly progressivism to hide their predatory behaviour) or selling the lifestyle of the tradwife beneath a deliberate veneer of empowerment. In any case, whatever good, self-affirming things witchcraft brought into Elaine’s life clearly pales in comparison to the way the men in her life can so easily coopt her beliefs for their own gain, and how easily she lets them.

Samantha Robinson is fantastic as Elaine, completely capturing the slightly exaggerated mannerisms and facial expressions of actresses in this era and genre. It’s hard to describe, but there’s a deliberateness to every blink and gesture that’s just captivating to behold (again, think Marcia of The Brady Bunch). At various points you sympathise with her, though seconds later she’ll remind you that she’s a complete psychopath. Are we meant to cheer at her tearful disposal of the various chauvinists she crosses paths with, or do we get frustrated at her hopelessly pathetic need for male validation?

Is she is a victim or a predator? Is she sincere in her desire for love, or is she subliminally trying to punish the men in her life? Is she self-objectifying herself for the male gaze as a way of gaining power, and if so – can that ever be a good thing? I asked some of these questions when I wrote about Stacie Munroe from Hustle, though there was one key difference there: Stacie had self-respect.

There’s a lot here to absorb, far more than one viewing can provide. I’ll mull it all over for a while, and then come back for more. Until then, it remains a very funny movie. At one point Elaine’s voiceover points out that most men have never seen a used tampon in their lives, and later two cops find one in a witch bottle. One promptly cries out in horror: “what the hell is that?!” I laughed extremely hard.

The Body in the Library (2004)

Sick days are swiftly becoming Marple days. There’s just something very lulling about Agatha Christie adaptations when you’re feeling crook. This one just happens to be based on the very first Christie book I ever read, so I’m rather fond of it for that reason, even if they take a few questionable liberties (including changing the identity of one of the killers!)

In an attempt to poke fun at a major cliché of crime novels at the time, Christie opens the story with a body in a library – though it’s a sensational body found in a profoundly ordinary library (no hidden doors or secret tunnels, as was the literary craze at the time). The library belongs to Arthur and Dolly Bantry, the latter of whom is good friends with Jane Marple, who naturally becomes involved.

The body is identified as that of Ruby Keene, a young dancer at the Majestic Hotel, so there the intrepid team of Jane and Dolly go to investigate further. As usual, this is packed full of British thespians who want to tick “Agatha Christie mystery” off their resumes: Joanna Lumley, Tara Fitzgerald, David Walliams, Simon Callow, James Fox, Ben Miller and Jack Davenport (who I’d totally forgotten was in this).

SPOILERS

Only Mary Stockley remains a relative unknown, and she’s not great in the pivotal role of Josie. At one point she has to be genuinely confused (and trying to hide it) and later genuinely angry (another important reaction/clue) and that doesn’t come across in her performance at all. She’s eventually revealed as one of the killers, as per the book, and quite a monstrous one given that she and her accomplice kill two innocent girls to get their hands on an inheritance.

But they change the identity of the other killer from Mark to Adelaide, and I’ve no idea why. It doesn’t change the plot in any fundamental way since the motive and means remain entirely the same, and if the purpose was to add some LGBTQIA+ rep to the proceedings, I’m not entirely sure the rainbow community would thank the show for adding Psycho Lesbians.

Edit: I had this posted no more than a couple of days before the David Walliams accusations dropped. Yeesh.

Charmed: Season 2 (2019 – 2020)

Contrary to my usual take on such matters, I don’t think reboots are all bad. Charmed in particular was a show tailor-made for a revamp in order to iron out some of the continuity errors and tonal issues and cheesy elements of the original. Concepts such as the Elders, the Source, the White/Darklighters and the show’s time travelling escapades all carried a lot of potential, and any remake provided a prime opportunity for a new batch of writers to craft more consistent stories with the largely untapped or misused ideas of the original.

To be fair, I’m only familiar with the first season of the original Charmed, having tapped out about halfway through the third for a number of reasons (recasting issues, bad outfits, sloppy writing, the impending death of Prue – and yes, I’m very aware of the irony that this show will soon do the exact same thing with the exact same sister, but back in the nineties, the show very quickly lost its – well, charm).

Another difference is that when Charmed first aired, standalone episodes were the norm. Sure there were a few ongoing developments across the episodes (the mystery of Leo’s true identity, the intrigues at Bucklands Auction House), but for the most part you would tune in and get a complete story in forty-five minutes. These days television episodes are like chapters in a book; small parts of a greater whole with endings that flow straight into the next instalment. Often a single episode will involve a specific task to complete or problem to solve, but they’re always part of a bigger picture. Even in shows that still pull up to nineteen episodes per season (as this does) there’s no such thing as filler.

Furthermore, networks like the CW have very much settled into a formula for their genre shows. Well, not a formula exactly, but a system that works for serialized long-form stories. There’ll be an ongoing mystery that involves a few twists, familiar guest-stars popping in and out, some moral conundrums to be struggled with, and an array of love interests whose longevity will probably be decided on by their popularity in the fandom.

This has its advantages in comparison to the one-offs, but I still miss the standalones. They guaranteed you a few duds and a few truly excellent offerings, and half the fun was sitting down once a week to find out which one you’d get. Now there’s no Early Instalment Weirdness, no characters that are Dropped After the Pilot, no throwing things at the wall to see what works and what doesn’t – just a streamlined story-arc from the word go.

Also missing are the silly little subplots, in which one of the Halliwell sisters would have to deal with the A-plot (usually involving life-or-death stakes) while the others would be dealing with normal, everyday problems (usually solved or exacerbated by their powers) such as an employee who keeps breaking things because he’s nervous about proposing to his girlfriend, or feeling guilty about covering for a new boss when they’re clearly cheating on their partner. Sure, this could lead to some bizarre tonal whiplash, but it was also where a lot of character work was done. There’s none of that here; it’s all action, all the time.

Oh, and one more thing – watching this show made me realize the lost art of mini-cliffhangers for ad-breaks. That’s another thing streaming took away from us!

Okay, I should probably describe what actually happens this season. The sisters find themselves under attack from a masked and hooded assassin which necessitates their relocation to Seattle. Though their house goes with them via magical means, all of their friends and remaining family are led to believe they’re dead, and to make matters even worse, they’ve lost all their powers.

These are the first of many odd creative decisions, as it completely robs the characters of the university setting that made up so much of the first season’s vibe (providing them with resources and social activities) and instead putting them in the basement of a community centre called SafeSpace. And I really cannot fathom why anyone would want to write a witch show in which said witches can’t even perform any magic.

With all the Whitelighters and Elders dead (yeah, this apparently happened in the first season, and it’s another unfathomable decision), the sisters take over the Command Centre situated beneath SafeSpace and do their best to rescue various witches from across America who are being targeted by demon factions. From this point on, there are a number of different subplots involving political intrigue and romantic entanglements, most notably the introduction of Abigael, sister of Parker (Maggie’s demon love interest in the first season) with ambitions to take over the demon clans as their Overlord, and Harry realizing that the assassin is his evil foil, a Darklighter comprised of all his negative emotions after they were removed from him when he became a Whitelighter.

The Whitelighters were one of the more unique ideas in the original Charmed, a collection of supernatural beings who were essentially guardian angels to witches across the world, while their counterparts the Darklighters had similar powers, but were tasked with killing witches instead of protecting them. Because I’m only familiar with the first season of nineties’ Charmed, I’ve no idea whether the lore used in the 2018 version ever turned up on the original show, but it’s a reasonably clever concept to play around with: defining Darklighters as the negative half of a Whitelighter’s former mortal self.

With that in mind, it’s unsurprising that Rupert Evans, who plays Harry, is also in the role of his Darklighter. Perhaps he takes up a little too much of the screentime (I don’t recall Leo ever getting this level of narrative attention) but I do like the fact that he has a relationship with all three sisters and not just his love interest (Leo only ever seemed to talk to Piper back on the original show). Our sister-witch protagonists are fine, though the writing isn’t particularly strong for them this season, and they hardly seem to spend any meaningful time together. Meanwhile, Poppy Drayton (Abigael) comes across a bit too prim and proper for a character who’s meant to be a sexpot.

But Jordan Donica (currently on The Gilded Age as Peggy’s new fiancé) is present in a fairly meaty recurring role, and I got a kick out of seeing Eric Balfour and Azura Skye as guest-stars. Why? Because both of them played minor but reasonably significant characters at the very beginning and very end of Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Jesse and Cassie from the first and seventh seasons.

Luna Nera: Season 1 (2020)

I’ve had gif-sets of this show liked on my Tumblr page for years, so it feels good to finally watch this and transfer them to the queue, though unfortunately I was under the impression this was a one-and-done limited series. It’s actually another cancelled project.

Ah well, at least the visuals were nice, and the pleasant thing about international films/shows is that they’re full of unfamiliar faces and talent.

The show is set in Serra, Italy, in the seventeenth century, where a midwife called Natalia and her granddaughter Ade find themselves in trouble after predicting the death of a newborn during the mother’s difficult labour. They become targets of the Benandanti, a group of witch-hunters, and Ade is told to seek refuge in the Lost Cities, where witches are said to hide in a magically concealed (and very artfully dilapidated) fortress. Meanwhile, Natalia hides a book of magic in the house that only Ade can retrieve – though it’s unclear why she couldn’t just take the book with her to the Lost Cities.

Ade meets a boy called Pietro who is studying medicine and staunchly rejects the existence of magic, so of course they fall in love and of course he turns out to be the son of the leader of the Benandanti. They carry on a secret love affair as Ade helps the witches in the Lost Cities locate and rescue other women accused of witchcraft that she can sense with her magic.

It’s rather choppy, all things considered, with characters u-turning their motivations and attitudes at a moment’s notice. Another young witch is jealous to the point of getting physical with Ade over her gifts, but after a scolding from their elders, the two become instant BFFS. Pietro is an exasperating character who constantly flip-flops between loving and hating Ade (if he was simply a little conflicted, that would be one thing, but he goes from proposing marriage to leading the witch-burning misogynists without much any in between).

The structure is a bit weird as well; the show had two big twists concerning the true identities of a couple of characters, but neither of them landed particularly well. Still, I can’t complain too much about a show stacked with female characters, especially when quite good portion of them are in their fifties and still fighting, riding, spellcasting and loving each other. It also features one of my favourite love-to-hate types of female character: the girl who carries water for the patriarchy, only to realize it’s going to stab her in the back the first chance it gets. Such is the case of Pietro’s foster sister Cesaria, whose story is sadly cut short before she gets a chance to act on her betrayal.

I can’t fully recommend it, especially with that cliffhanger ending, but I’m glad I watched it at least once.

2 comments:

  1. > Again, no explanation of how a vampire might revert back to a human being. The transformation is usually depicted as permanent.

    Might I take this opportunity to shamelessly promote this thing I wrote tangentially related to this subject?: https://cwickham.blogspot.com/2025/05/like-goddamn-vampire.html

    > Do they even publish these officially sanctioned glorified paperback fan-fics for shows anymore?

    Back in the day those ones for Buffy were absolutely *everywhere* in the UK. They were being given away free with magazines in a way that looked suspiciously like a publisher trying to shift unsold stock. I walked into a charity shop once that had so many of them they were asking everyone who entered the shop if they were a fan of Buffy.

    > Also, someone called David Sterne who certainly looked familiar,

    Oh David Sterne has been making a living out of playing 'grumpy old man' as a guest spot in British TV for at least thirty years. To the point that at least one show (I won't name what because I think it's on your to-watch list!) seems to cast him to deliberately misdirect the audience about the character.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Might I take this opportunity to shamelessly promote this thing I wrote tangentially related to this subject?: https://cwickham.blogspot.com/2025/05/like-goddamn-vampire.html

    Gotta say I've never heard of Dracula Dobbs, but that comic strip definitely seems to be the same flavour of vampire story as "Little Vampires" in BSC.

    Back in the day those ones for Buffy were absolutely *everywhere* in the UK. They were being given away free with magazines in a way that looked suspiciously like a publisher trying to shift unsold stock. I walked into a charity shop once that had so many of them they were asking everyone who entered the shop if they were a fan of Buffy.

    That actually sounds wonderful. I wish I could time travel back to that point and get my hands on "Tales of the Slayers" which are now out of print and worth thousands!

    Oh David Sterne has been making a living out of playing 'grumpy old man' as a guest spot in British TV for at least thirty years. To the point that at least one show (I won't name what because I think it's on your to-watch list!) seems to cast him to deliberately misdirect the audience about the character.

    I may have to trawl IMDB in search of him. Crazy how often he's popped up without me noticing.

    ReplyDelete