Reading/Watching Log #59

This is essentially the second half of my Halloween viewing, featuring several horror movies and shows, though I evened it all out with a glut of children’s books. It was a mixed bag this month, with some stuff that I really didn’t enjoy and only absorbed because of my annoying need to finish everything I’ve started – and once again, I ended up watching some stuff that didn’t strictly adhere to my New Year’s Resolution.

But there’s some good stuff too. I revisited the Scream trilogy for the first time in years, as well as Pan’s Labyrinth, once of my all-time favourite films. I finally watched Over the Garden Wall and Fleabag, highly rated television that I’ve been meaning to get to for years, and finished several books series by Robin Stevens and Cressida Cowell that I’m going to remember fondly.

Plus, I went to the ballet, which is always a treat.

His Dark Materials: Theft

 It only took one and a half seasons, but for the first time this show managed to inject a sense of urgency into the proceedings. That is, the feeling that important things might be at stake, that characters might have to pick up the pace, and that there could (excepting Roger’s death) be actual consequences if the right things don’t happen at the right time.

Sorry to be so scathing, but this show still struggles with conveying the sheer momentousness of the themes and events that the book trilogy captured so effortlessly. Never underestimate the need for urgency in any given story.

This is an episode marked by the way its characters are all looking for something: people, artefacts, answers. For Lee Scoresby, it’s a straightforward quest to find Stanislaus Grumman (though only the most obtuse won’t have realized by this stage that Grumman and Will’s father are one and the same). For the likes of Lord Boreal, it’s the promise of a powerful weapon that was teased throughout the last season, and is here described for the first time. For Mary, it’s a basic understanding of the bizarre events that have converged in her office over the past couple of days.

And for Lyra and Will, it’s a double-whammy: Lyra wants to know more about Dust, Will wants to find his father, and – as is becoming increasingly clear – both those goals are interjoined. Interestingly enough, Lyra begins this episode with prioritizing her own situation for Roger’s sake, even though Pan (who let’s remember, is her deeper self) argues that they should follow the instructions of the alethiometer and assist Will in the search for his father.

It’s a “do this in order to get to that” situation, and with the power of hindsight (and with having the book at hand) you can see what’s at work here is the show setting up the thoroughfare between Lyra losing the alethiometer and Will gaining the Subtle Knife.

His Dark Materials: The Cave

This episode, as well as the chapters they’re based on, are all about intel gathering. As Lyra goes to a natural history museum and a nearby college to learn more about this world’s understanding of Dust, Will contacts the family lawyer and learns that his paternal grandparents are living in Oxford.

There are some minor changes between this material and the book, but some of Jack Thorpe’s earlier creative decisions are beginning to pay off. Most of them involve Lord Boreal, who has emerged as an active cohort of Mrs Coulter, revealed last season as a man who had access to the windows across dimensions.

At the time it felt like padding, but now we can see how it fits into the wider narrative: Pullman doesn’t bother to explain any of Lord Boreal's movements or abilities in the book – he coincidentally spots Lyra at the museum and she vaguely recognizes him from the cocktail party way back in Northern Lights.

No spoilers, but his part to play is very minor and we get no understanding whatsoever as to how he managed to move from one world to the next. Here, we know that he’s also been using the window that Lyra and Will have accessed (and presumably, several more) making it far less of a coincidence that he would be at the right time and place to spot them emerging from the traffic island into the streets of Will’s Oxford.

He’s obviously able to recognize Lyra, but Thorpe has also written him as the man behind the pursuit of John Parry’s letters, giving the children a common enemy and providing linkage between their parallel quests. I can’t believe I’m saying this, but well played Jack Thorpe. It makes me wonder if some of his other additions (the witch politics, the Magisterium machinations) will have a greater narrative purpose than just filling in time.

Xena Warrior Princess: Forgiven, King Con, When in Rome...

 The next three episodes are a mixed bag in the sense that two make several questionable creative decisions and the other is genuinely my favourite Xena Warrior Princess episode of all time. It’s the show at its cleverest and wittiest, whilst maintaining a fairly solid plot and forcing its two leads to confront serious ethical quandaries.

All of the Rome-centric episodes can be relied upon to be of above-average quality, but When In Rome somehow manages to be a cut above the rest: drawing on events past and present (mostly in regards to Caesar), concocting a fairly intelligent Rescue Plot, confronting Xena and Gabrielle with their recent trust issues, and stacking the cast with solid guest stars.

The episode makes it onto numerous “best of” or “top ten” Xena episode lists, but I’m probably alone in making it my #1.

His Dark Materials: The City of Magpies

We’re back with the second season of His Dark Materials, which (I’m safely assuming) covers the entirety of The Subtle Knife, the middle book of the trilogy. I’m hoping for an uptick in quality, if not simply because this is brand new material to be adapted, and the series no longer has to sit in the shadow of the 2007 film. (Not that the film was any good, but there was still a sense of contrast/compare at work).

I’ll start with an unpopular opinion: The Subtle Knife is actually my favourite book of the three, though I couldn’t really tell you why. There is some fair criticism that the narrative shifted from Lyra to Will Parry as the story’s protagonist, and I can fully understand why this would be so infuriating, especially after how vividly she was brought to life in Northern Lights.

And yet… I actually prefer the introspective Will to the more rambunctious Lyra, even if that’s purely down to who I relate to more. (That said, the problem of gender-perspective becomes even more egregious in The Amber Spyglass, in which Lyra spends the first few chapters as an unconscious damsel in distress).

The Subtle Knife also taught me that not every plot-point has to be explained, whether it’s John Parry inexplicably being in possession Lee Scoresby’s ring or the unexplained images on the upper right-hand corner of each page (they denote what world the action is currently taking place in, but the reader has to figure that out for themselves), and rendered so many extraordinary landscapes (the streets of Cittàgazze) and heart-stopping sequences (Will and Lyra using the knife to move between worlds in the attempt to steal back her alethiometer).

Reading it for the first time was like flying; I’ll never forget how utterly riveting and immersive it was. Even the tiniest of thought-provoking details, like Lyra entering the museum and seeing the sleigh that took her to Bolvangar or Will pondering the linked etymology between amber and electricity stayed with me for years.

Season two kicks off with a gathering of forces, setting up the three major strands of the episode: Lyra and Will meeting in Cittàgazze, Lee Scoresby accompanying Serafina to the witch enclave, and Mrs Coulter undergoing her usual machinations onboard a Magisterium vessel. So, let’s go through them in order:

Links and Updates

 Holy shit, that was one heck of a weekend. How we feeling guys?

Trump has been ousted, Biden and Harris won the day, Giuliani led a press conference in a parking lot due to a screwup in the booking, a serious fistfight broke out at my library (not politically related, but still extremely violent and upsetting), Putin was falsely rumoured to be resigning… and apparently Dean and Castiel from Supernatural are canon now? Only for one half of that ship to die immediately afterwards? Which still managed to start trending on Twitter in the midst of the election chaos?

This probably summed it up as well as anything can:

It’s a lot to process: I’ve been high on serotonin for the past twenty-four hours, blaring NSYNC’s Bye Bye Bye on the headphones, and scrolling through the thousands of memes that have flooded the various internet dashboards. Saturday I came home still reluctant to call the race due to my deeply superstitious fear of jinxing things; now it’s Sunday night and I’m just relaxing.

Here’s some fandom related news, since technically that’s what this blog is meant to be about…

Legend of the Seeker: Brennidon

The one in which they try to make us interested in Richard’s secret biological family.

It’s a trope well-known to fantasy fiction: that the protagonist will have some sort of secret lineage that elevates him to a position of “specialness”, often compounded by a mystical prophecy surrounding the circumstances of his birth and detailing the great stuff he’s destined to do as an adult. Honestly, the number of fantasy heroes that don’t have this as an intrinsic part of their backstory are far outnumbered by the ones that do. From Luke Skywalker to Harry Potter, King Arthur to any one of the Greek heroes that were secretly sired by Zeus – a significant parentage and a great destiny go hand in hand.

And with that comes a tried-and-true method of trying to circumvent the above hero from rising: what TV Tropes calls Nice Job Breaking It Herod. The bad guy knows that a destined hero who poses a threat to his monopoly on power has been born somewhere in the vicinity, and so sends out his troops to make sure he never reaches manhood – and just to make sure the job is done properly, usually decrees that there’s no real need for accuracy. If there’s a baby, kill it.  

It’s a pretty popular story in the Bible, from Moses escaping the Pharaoh’s genocide of the slave children, to King Herod sending his men out to kill Baby Jesus, but it pops up across various times and cultures: Saturn devours his own children to prevent one of them from overthrowing him, Krishna narrowly avoids the same fate at the hands of his uncle Kamsa, and Greek mythology is veritably full of baby princes who are saved by helpful shepherds who find them left to die of exposure on various hilltops because they’ll one day overthrow their fathers.

Harry Potter was targeted by Voldemort because a prophecy stated he would be his enemy’s downfall, and Jon Snow had to grow up as a disgraced bastard because his true lineage made him too vulnerable to assassination attempts. In a rare case of a heroic character greenlighting this procedure, King Arthur once ordered the drowning of babies born on May Day in an attempt to avoid the destruction that Mordred would one day unleash on Camelot, and in an even rarer female example, Willow depicted Elora Danan being hunted down as a baby after she’s foretold as being the one who will defeat the evil Queen Bavmorda (that movie ended on a weird subversion of this trope, since she didn’t have any sort of direct hand in the destruction of Bavmorda. So… was she a normal baby the whole time, and it was just the efforts of good people to protect an innocent that was the true saviour? Unclear).

You could even make a case for The Terminator movies being based on this, though the titular Terminator goes back a step in time and targets the Chosen One’s mother.

My point in bringing all this up is that Legend of the Seeker also goes to the same well in drawing up a backstory for Richard Cypher – but for some reason, whether it’s because the trope is as old as time, or because the show adds no interesting wrinkles to the familiar setup – it’s as uninteresting as it is unnecessary. Like, seriously unnecessary. I’m not sure what they do with the remaining mystery of Richard’s father in season two, but by the end of this season the revelations of his paternity and family tree which are presumably meant to rock his world, have absolutely no bearing on his character or the resolution of the plot.

It’s really quite bizarre.