My assignment is finished! Time to celebrate!
It's been over a decade since X-Men Evolution first aired between 2000 and 2003, but I enjoyed it enough to record most of the episodes on videotape – yes, in those days we had to resort to such arcane measures if we wanted to have copies of our favourite shows. My sister in particular completely loved it, and though those old tapes are long gone, all four seasons of the show are now freely available on YouTube.
One of the biggest questions that arise when you're about to rewatch something you haven't seen in years is: will it hold up? There have been so many films and books I wish I'd never tracked down again because my memories of them were so rosy it was inevitably a let-down when I returned to them as an adult.
But I'm happy to say that X-Men Evolution is still pretty good. Not without its flaws, but still a coherent and rewarding piece of television. Like I said in my last post, the inevitable point of comparison is X-Men: TAS, which (as much as I adored it as a kid) has not aged well. It's certainly not unwatchable, but I can't help but feel that a viewer unused to the distinctive style of nineties cartoons would be utterly bewildered by it. And possibly a bit scared as well.
But X-Men Evolution is something you could sit a small child in front of, knowing they would understand the gist of what was going on – at least most of the time. So here's my controversial opinion that will no doubt draw the ire of anyone out there in their late twenties/early thirties: X-Men Evolution tells a better overarching story than X-Men: TAS. Indubitably.